Medical Malpractice

What Is the Average Settlement for Amputation in New York?

November 22, 2023
What Is the Average Settlement for Amputation in New York?

Table Of Contents


Amputation injuries have profound and lasting effects on individuals, often resulting in physical, emotional, and financial hardships. Victims of these life-altering accidents can rely on the guidance of an amputation attorney as they seek compensation.

Determining the average settlement for amputation or loss of limb cases in New York can be complex. Variables such as the severity of the amputation injury, medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, and long-term care requirements all influence the final settlement amount.

In this article, we will delve into cases involving amputation injuries and explore the challenges associated with calculating the average settlement for such cases in the state of New York.

What Causes an Amputation Injury?

Understanding the most common causes of amputation injuries empowers individuals and organizations to take proactive steps toward preventing them. Victims have suffered amputations due to various types of accidents:

Work Accidents

Work Accidents

In workplaces where heavy machinery and equipment are used, amputations can result from accidents caused by inadequate safety precautions or insufficient training.

Employers should prioritize workplace safety by implementing strict protocols, providing proper training, and regularly maintaining equipment. Safety measures such as machine guards and personal protective equipment can significantly reduce the risk of workplace injuries.

Motor Vehicle Accidents

Amputations can occur in high-speed collisions, such as motorcycle accidents and car accidents. These accidents may result from factors like reckless driving, impaired driving, or failure to wear a seat belt.

Stricter enforcement of traffic laws and the promotion of defensive driving practices can help prevent amputations stemming from vehicle accidents.

Slip and Fall Accidents

Injuries due to slip and fall accidents can lead to a leg amputation, especially for someone with a preexisting medical condition. Factors such as poor lighting, obstacles in walkways, and wet or slippery surfaces contribute to these accidents.

Proper building maintenance, clear walkways, and prompt attention to hazards can help prevent slip and fall incidents, reducing the risk of amputations.

Firearm and Explosive Accidents

Accidental discharge of firearms or mishandling of explosives can result in a catastrophic injury like an amputation. Responsible firearm ownership, including proper training and secure storage, is essential to prevent these accidents. Individuals working with explosives must receive thorough training and adhere to stringent safety protocols to minimize the risk of the loss of a body part.

Public education campaigns on firearm safety and the dangers of explosives can further prevent such incidents.

Medical Malpractice Incidents

Amputations can result from surgical errors or misdiagnoses. Patients can protect themselves by seeking medical care from reputable professionals, obtaining second opinions when necessary, and actively participating in their healthcare decisions. Healthcare facilities must maintain high standards of care and accountability to prevent unnecessary amputations.

Factors Influencing an Amputation Settlement

Settlement amounts for any personal injury case, including amputation cases, are influenced by several crucial factors.

Severity and Level of the Amputation

Severity and Level of the Amputation

The severity and level of the amputation are large factors in the outcomes of personal injury lawsuits. More extensive limb loss, such as a leg amputated above the knee or the loss of multiple limbs, tends to result in larger settlements due to the increased impact on the victim's life.

Other body parts, like an amputated thumb or toe, may yield smaller settlements. The extent of physical and emotional suffering, as well as lost wages, is also considered when determining the settlement.

Cause of the Amputation

The cause of the amputation significantly affects the average settlement for loss of limb. Amputations due to surgical errors or misdiagnoses can result in substantial awards. Additionally, amputations resulting from defective products might result in larger settlements. A car accident amputation settlement can vary widely based on factors like which driver was at fault.

In general, preventable accidents and instances of clear liability tend to lead to higher settlements than cases that are less clear-cut.

Degree of Fault

The role of fault in amputation settlements is especially pronounced in New York, where the comparative negligence rule applies. If you are found partially responsible for the accident that led to limb loss, your compensation is reduced proportionately.

For instance, if a car accident resulted in an initial $1 million award, but your actions contributed to 20% of the incident, your settlement would be adjusted to $800,000. Evaluating liability and considering comparative fault are critical steps in determining the final settlement amount.

Age and Occupation of the Amputee

The age and occupation of the amputee are key factors influencing the average case value. Younger amputees typically receive larger settlements because they have longer expected life spans, resulting in more years of disability and lost earning capacity.

Occupations also play a role; high-earning professionals like surgeons or executives can seek larger settlements compared to low-wage workers. In contrast, older, retired amputees who are no longer in the workforce may receive smaller settlements that do not include lost wages.

Long-Term Care and Assistive Devices Needed

The long-term care and assistive devices an amputee will require heavily influence settlement amounts. Factors considered include costs for rehabilitation services, wheelchairs, prosthetics, home healthcare, and accessibility modifications.

Lifetime expenses for medications, physical therapy, and follow-up surgeries are also calculated. Settlements are adjusted to account for amputees who require more comprehensive and expensive long-term treatment, as well as those who have greater accessibility needs.

Policy Limits

The insurance policy limits of the liable parties can impact an amputation settlement. If the responsible party's insurance policy has low coverage limits, it may be challenging to obtain financial compensation beyond these limits.

Plaintiffs may explore other avenues for compensation if the policy limits cannot fully cover their losses, such as pursuing legal action against additional parties or trying to collect compensation directly from the responsible party.

Claimants and their legal teams must understand these critical factors to negotiate fair settlements that adequately address the physical, emotional, and financial impact of limb loss.

Determining the Value of Amputation Claims

Amputation claims involve assessing various types of losses to determine their overall value. These encompass both economic and non-economic losses:

  • Financial losses due to the amputation injury include medical bills, lost wages due to disability, and anticipated future expenses related to medical care, rehabilitation, and prosthetics.
  • Property damage may be factored in, such as if personal belongings or items were lost, damaged, or broken during the incident leading to the amputation
  • Intangible losses (non-economic damages) include pain and suffering, emotional distress, and the impact on one's overall quality of life.
  • Rarely, punitive damages may come into play, serving as a deterrent and punishment for the responsible party's reckless or intentional actions.

Average Settlements for Amputation in New York and Case Examples

Amputation personal injury cases in New York can result in a wide range of settlement outcomes. These case examples handled by Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm illustrate the diversity of amputation settlements.

Case 1: Delayed Diagnosis of Squamous Cell Carcinoma

Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm is currently litigating this tragic case, which involves a middle-aged man with a history of HIV and Kaposi's sarcoma. For over a year, the patient repeatedly sought medical attention for a significant ulceration on his big toe accompanied by intense pain. Healthcare providers conducted imaging studies and prescribed antibiotics, but they failed to perform a biopsy to determine the cause of the disease.

This lapse led to a delay in the diagnosis and treatment of a Marjolin's ulcer and squamous cell carcinoma. As a result, the patient underwent multiple amputations and chemotherapy, and he ultimately succumbed to the disease. This case underscores the devastating consequences of delayed cancer diagnosis.

Case 2: Negligence in Knee Replacement Surgery Clearance

In another significant case, Bradley S. Zimmerman, Esq., achieved a substantial settlement on behalf of a 67-year-old man who underwent knee replacement surgery after being negligently cleared by his treating cardiologist and orthopedic surgeon. The patient had numerous severe health conditions, including hypertension, high cholesterol, diabetes, obesity, and renal failure. Despite the patient's risk factors, he was cleared for surgery.

Following the procedure, the patient experienced a significant drop in hemoglobin levels, inducing atrial fibrillation. Delayed blood transfusions resulted in thrombotic occlusion, leading to the amputation of his leg. The patient spent the remainder of his life in rehabilitation therapy and eventually passed away. This case highlights the importance of holding medical professionals accountable for their actions and the devastating injuries suffered by the patient.

If you or a loved one has experienced an amputation due to an accident or an instance of medical malpractice, it's crucial to consult with a skilled personal injury attorney. An attorney can assess the unique details of your personal injury case and advocate for the compensation you deserve. They will consider factors such as liability, insurance coverage, and the long-term impact of the amputated limb on your life.

Amputation settlements in New York encompass a broad spectrum, and the actual amounts hinge on the specific circumstances of each personal injury case.

Estimated Settlements for Amputation in NY
Type of Amputation Settlement Amount
Traumatic leg amputation $4.2 million
Average settlement for amputation $3 million
Medical malpractice amputation $3.5 million
Work-related amputation $3 million
Amputation of multiple limbs $2.5 million
Amputation of a hand or foot $1.5 million
Amputation of a finger or toe $500,000
Leg amputation settlement amounts $4.2 million
Arm amputation settlement amounts $3.5 million
Below-the-knee amputation settlements $3.7 million
Partial finger amputation settlement $250,000

Consulting with an experienced attorney at Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm could make a significant difference in securing a fair and just settlement.

Factors to Consider in Amputation Settlement Negotiations

Settlement negotiations for amputation cases are intricate processes. The strength of evidence and liability holds significant weight; a solid case that demonstrates the defendant's fault and the extent of the plaintiff's damages can expedite negotiations. Insurance coverage limits are another pivotal consideration, as settlements with insurance providers cannot exceed available policy limits.

Additionally, the unique circumstances of each case, such as the severity of the amputation, long-term care needs, and the overall impact on the plaintiff's life, significantly shape negotiation dynamics.

The negotiation skills of the claimant's attorney are vital in driving the process forward effectively. An experienced attorney can represent their client's interests skillfully and work toward full compensation after filing a personal injury lawsuit.

Need Legal Guidance for Amputation Settlements?

Get insightful advice on personal injury amputation settlements from Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm.

Contact Us Today!

Know Your Rights and Negotiate for Maximum Settlement at Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm!

In amputation personal injury cases, seeking professional legal representation is crucial. At Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm, our experienced attorneys are committed to advocating for your rights in amputation cases. Don't navigate the complexities alone — let us help you get the compensation you deserve.

Determine the Full Value of Your Claim