# The Unresolved Fee Question in New York MIF Cases Against the U.S.

- Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm
- /

- Blog
- /blog

- New York MIF & FTCA Attorney Fees
- New York MIF & FTCA Attorney Fees

Birth Injuries

## The Unresolved Fee Question in New York MIF Cases Against the U.S.

November 16, 2026

> Reprinted with permission from the November 9, 2026 edition of The New York Law Journal © 2026 ALM Media Properties, LLC. All rights reserved. Further duplication without permission is prohibited, contact [(877) 257-3382](tel:+18772573382) or [reprints@alm.com](mailto:reprints@alm.com).

The Federal Tort Claims Act (“FTCA”) provides individuals with a judicial remedy when they suffer injury due to the negligence or wrongful conduct of federal government employees. Congress intended the FTCA to waive the federal government’s sovereign immunity for certain tort claims, allowing the government to be held liable in the same way a private individual would be under comparable circumstances. In many ways, the FTCA puts the federal government in a position similar to that of a private defendant in a civil action.

But one key gap remains. While the FTCA caps the attorneys’ fees plaintiffs’ counsel may collect, it does not expressly require the federal government to pay fees in addition to the settlement amount or damage award. This point becomes particularly problematic in cases involving the New York State Medical Indemnity Fund (“MIF”) because the U.S. has suggested in these cases that it can claim the MIF’s chief benefit — immunity from paying future medical expenses — while refusing the obligation that comes with it — paying the attorneys’ fees on those damages.

## An MIF Primer

The New York State Legislature established the MIF in 2011 with the purpose of “provid[ing] a funding source for future health care costs associated with birth related neurological injuries, in order to reduce premium costs for medical malpractice insurance coverage”. N.Y. Pub. Health Law § 2999-g.

The mechanics of the MIF require any “qualified plaintiff” — that is, any infant who sustained a “birth related neurological injury” or brain/spinal injury occurring during their birth, delivery, resuscitation, and/or delivery admission, because of medical malpractice or alleged malpractice — to waive their right to recover damages for future medical expenses in exchange for being enrolled in the MIF. N.Y. Pub. Health Law § 2999-j(6). In exchange, the MIF pays all future medical expenses, and the defendants must pay attorneys’ fees on the portion of any settlement or verdict attributed to, or allocated to, damages for future medical expenses. N.Y. Pub. Health Law § 2999-j(14).

The statute is explicit: attorneys’ fees are “based upon the entire sum awarded by the jury or the court or the full sum of the settlement” and are “paid in a lump sum by the defendants”. *Id.* So if a jury awards a qualified plaintiff $30 million in future medical expenses, the defendant pays none of that $30 million (because the plaintiff waived those damages) but owes the proportional attorneys’ fee on it — likely somewhat more than $3 million.

With settlements, parties typically agree on a cash settlement and then work backward to a higher “total settlement value” that includes an allocation to future medical expenses. Courts generally accept a 50/50 split between MIF and non-MIF damages, depending on the specific facts. Fees are calculated on the total settlement value but paid out of the cash settlement, so the defendant never pays more than the agreed cash amount.

## When the FTCA Meets the MIF

Presumably, under the FTCA, the same MIF requirements apply to the federal government as a defendant as they do to any other defendant in New York. However, this result has not yet been fully established or adjudicated. To date, no published FTCA cases involve a verdict and the MIF, although numerous court orders and/or decisions have approved settlements. In most of these settlements, counsel submits an Infant Compromise Order (“ICO”) seeking attorneys’ fees, which the judge then approves.

A recent case is illustrative. In *Shinagawa v. U.S.,* 2025 WL 1009384 (S.D.N.Y. April 4, 2025) — a case in which my law firm was involved — a child was alleged to have suffered hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy and other birth-related neurological injuries during his birth and delivery because of a Federally Qualified Health Center employee’s failure to timely perform a C-section and her negligent vacuum delivery. The parties stipulated the child was a qualified plaintiff who would need to be enrolled in the MIF and would not be entitled to recover damages for future medical expenses, and that the delivering provider was deemed a Public Health Service employee, making an FTCA claim against the United States the plaintiffs’ exclusive remedy.

The next question was how the FTCA and the MIF would allocate attorneys’ fees. Under the FTCA, attorneys’ fees are limited to 25%. In *Shinagawa*, the U.S. took the position that it would allow the plaintiffs’ attorneys to collect a maximum attorneys’ fee of 25% of the $2.5 million cash settlement, rather than 25% of the total settlement of $3,962,905, which included the mother’s derivative claim, stating it was the U.S.’s position that it could not allow attorneys’ fees on any amount not actually paid out by it *(i.e.*, the portion of the settlement allocated to the MIF). If the case involved private defendants, under the MIF, plaintiffs’ attorneys should have been entitled to attorneys’ fees of 25% of the total settlement. Although the court found plaintiffs’ counsel’s requested fees reasonable, counsel accepted the U.S.’s position rather than litigate a dispute that would have taken more money from the infant client — the bind plaintiffs’ attorneys routinely face in MIF cases.

Having settled without the issue being litigated, the case raised the question of what would happen if a similar case went to verdict against the U.S. Would it be required to pay the attorneys’ fees on an award for future medical expenses as required by the MIF like a private defendant would?

*Grunwald v. U.S.*, 2023 WL 4967106 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 3, 2023), a bench ruling from a U.S. Magistrate Judge and cited by the federal government in *Shinagawa*, is the only case that has come close to deciding this issue on the merits. In *Grunwald*, the court held that the FTCA does not expressly waive sovereign immunity for the recovery of attorneys’ fees and, therefore, attorneys’ fees cannot be awarded directly against the U.S.

Instead, the court held that attorneys’ fees must come out of a plaintiff’s recovery and should therefore be calculated based on the U.S.’s contribution to the settlement. Importantly, there was no discussion of the FTCA’s text at 28 U.S.C. §2674, which states: “The United States shall be liable, respecting the provisions of this title relating to tort claims, in the same manner and to the same extent as a private individual under like circumstances, but shall not be liable for interest before judgment or for punitive damages”.

The main basis for the *Grunwald* decision disallowing plaintiffs’ attorneys from recovering fees on an entire settlement was that the FTCA does not waive sovereign immunity, including any state attorneys’ fees or fee-shifting provisions. Furthermore, although state law controls “the Government’s substantive liability”, the court viewed attorneys’ fees as not affecting the U.S.’s substantive liability because limits on what an attorney may collect from their client do not reduce what the U.S. ultimately pays. Thus, as the *Grunwald* court noted, “disputes over attorney’s fees in FTCA cases are determined solely by federal law”.

*Grunwald*’s authority is thinner than it appears. The court relied on eight prior infant compromise orders, but not one decided the question on the merits. In most cases, plaintiffs’ counsel did not contest the point, likely because doing so meant arguing to take more money from their own client, especially as the FTCA’s 25% attorneys’ fee is a higher rate than allowed under the New York sliding scale. In the two cases where it was raised — *Z.H.W. v. U.S.* and *Anderson v. U.S.* — counsel ultimately accepted, for the infant’s benefit, a 25% fee on the U.S.’s payment. Both the *Grunwald* court and the U.S. are using plaintiffs’ attorneys’ acquiescence on this issue to force plaintiffs’ attorneys in other cases to do the same.

## Other Cases That Address When And How the Federal Government Must Pay Attorneys’ Fees Under the FTCA

The *Grunwald* court also cited other laws stating that state statutes governing attorneys’ fee awards are preempted by federal law and do not control the federal government. However, none of these involved situations like the MIF, where a normal, valid category of damages (future medical expenses) is explicitly taken away from MIF-qualified plaintiffs in exchange for enrollment in the MIF and a defendant’s payment of attorneys’ fees. The court’s closest analogy, *Sanchez v. U.S.*, 1999 WL 35808324 (S.D.N.Y. 1999), actually cuts against the U.S. The decision stressed that the fee would “come out of Plaintiff’s recovery”. That may describe a settlement, but not a verdict, where the MIF requires the defendant to pay the fee.

The U.S. Supreme Court and most circuits have interpreted whether state law or federal law governs categories of damages in FTCA cases, and all have determined that state law governs the extent of liability, damages awards, applicability of caps, and the standards for reviewing damages awards. In *Richards v. U.S*., 369 U.S. 1 (1962), the Supreme Court applied Missouri law (the deemed governing law), including its cap on damages. The Second Circuit agrees, *Gonzalez v. U.S.*, 80 F.4th 183 (2d Cir. 2023), and the Fifth Circuit has let the United States benefit from Louisiana’s malpractice cap even though it never contributed to the state’s fund, *Owens v. U.S.*, 935 F.2d 734 (5th Cir. 1991). In applying state law, courts “must apply the ‘whole law’ of the state where the act or omission occurred”, not just a portion. *See Cibula v. U.S.*, 551 F.3d 316 (4th Cir. 2009). Another notable case is *Stokes v. U.S.*, 967 F.3d 1034 (10th Cir. 2020), which held that if a court applies a state statute to a private party, it must apply all the statute’s requirements when the U.S. is a party.

Similarly, if a court applies the MIF to eliminate the requirement of the U.S. to pay future medical expenses, it should also apply the MIF requirement that a defendant pay the substituted damages of the attorneys’ fees on such future medical expense awards. A court cannot apply one portion of the MIF without the other. If the U.S. could use the MIF as a shield from future medical damages, but then use preemption as a sword to defeat the replacement category of damages, this would vitiate the FTCA statutory requirement that the U.S. “shall be liable . . . in the same manner and to the same extent as a private individual under like circumstances”. Without the MIF, the government would owe a $30 million future-medical award; with the MIF applied in full, it would owe roughly $3 million in fees. Applied selectively, it would owe nothing.

This is where *Grunwald*’s premise breaks down. The court treated fees as a matter of federal law because they do not change what the U.S. pays. But the MIF is not a fee-shifting statute; it is a substantive damages scheme that removes one category of damages and substitutes another — enrollment in the MIF plus the defendant’s payment of fees on the future-medical award. As the Ninth Circuit explained in *Jackson v. U.S.*, 881 F.2d 707 (9th Cir. 1989), a state law is substantive when it “affect[s] the amount the government ultimately pays”. That’s exactly what the MIF does. The U.S. does not dispute the MIF’s application — it simply wants to have its cake and eat it too.

## A Continuing Issue Affecting Settlement of Cases Involving Birth-Related Neurological Injuries

This interplay between the MIF and FTCA will become a significant issue in a case involving both statutes when a jury finds for a plaintiff, assuming the MIF remains solvent and continues to enroll infants. It remains to be seen whether the same logic the *Grunwald* court applied to MIF and FTCA settlements would apply to a verdict that affects the U.S.’s substantive liability and ultimate payout.

For now, in New York FTCA cases involving birth-related neurological injuries, plaintiffs’ attorneys should, as they map out their litigation and settlement strategies, consider whether MIF attorneys’ fees are payable. Whether they are will affect settlement negotiations, settlement decisions, and post-settlement discussions and hearings.

## Related Legal Insights

[Federal Government Agrees To $5M Brain Damage Settlement For Baby](https://www.fuchsberg.com/blog/feds-pay-5m-brain-damage-settlement-baby)

[Damages in Recent New York Birth Injury Cases](https://www.fuchsberg.com/blog/damages-in-new-york-birth-injury-cases)

[Birth Injury Compensation: How Much Can We Claim for Our Child in New York State?](https://www.fuchsberg.com/blog/understanding-right-compensation-birth-injury)

[A Complete Guide to Birth Injury Lawsuits](https://www.fuchsberg.com/blog/birth-trauma-litigation-process)

[Who Is Liable in a Birth Injury Case in NY?](https://www.fuchsberg.com/blog/who-is-liable-in-a-birth-injury-case-in-ny)

Understand Your Child’s Birth Injury Claim

[Discuss Your Child’s Case](https://www.fuchsberg.com/contact)

When a birth injury changes your child’s future, understanding your legal options matters. Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm can review your family’s circumstances and help you understand how New York’s Medical Indemnity Fund may affect your claim.

Get Guidance on a Federal Birth Injury Claim

[Request a Free Case Evaluation](https://www.fuchsberg.com/contact)

A birth injury claim involving a federally funded health care provider can raise complex questions about compensation and future medical care. Turn to Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm for a case evaluation and guidance on your family’s legal options.

Take the Next Step in Your Child’s Birth Injury Case

[Get a Free Consultation](https://www.fuchsberg.com/contact)

If you believe medical negligence caused your child’s birth-related neurological injury, you deserve clear answers about your legal options. Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm can evaluate your potential claim, explain how the FTCA and New York’s Medical Indemnity Fund may apply, and help you consider your next steps. Contact our team for a free, confidential consultation.

---

Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Firm — [https://www.fuchsberg.com/blog/new-york-mif-ftca-attorney-fees](https://www.fuchsberg.com/blog/new-york-mif-ftca-attorney-fees)